Shopping for sex toys — for yourself or someone else — shouldn't feel overwhelming. Whether you're buying your first vibe or adding to an already impressive collection, this guide cuts through the noise and tells you exactly what's worth buying in 2026.
We've organized this by category and budget so you can find the right pick without scrolling for an hour. All products are available on our store with discreet shipping.
Under $50: Great Entry-Level Picks
Best Cock Ring: Oxballs 8-Ball Cockring ($49)
Cock rings are one of the best-bang-for-your-buck purchases in gay sex toys. They enhance erections, intensify orgasms, and require zero learning curve. The Oxballs 8-Ball is a fan favorite — stretchy, comfortable, and designed for all sizes. The attached ball ring adds extra stimulation. If you're buying someone their first cock ring, this is the one.
Best Budget Paddle: 12 Inch Leather Impression Paddle ($38.99)
If your gift recipient has expressed any curiosity about impact play or BDSM, this leather paddle is a playful, approachable intro. The heart-shaped impression it leaves is equal parts sexy and fun. Great for couples looking to experiment.
$50–$100: Step Up Your Game
Best Dildo: Addiction Justin 8" Dildo – Rainbow ($53.99)
A realistic 8-inch dildo in a pride-worthy rainbow finish. Addiction's Justin is one of our best sellers for good reason: the right amount of girth, a realistic feel, and body-safe materials. Makes a great solo gift and an even better couple's toy.
Best Chest Harness: Aquarius PU Leather Chest Harness ($49.90)
A leather chest harness is the kind of gift that makes someone feel like their best self. This Aquarius piece works as kink gear, club wear, or both. The half-sleeve detail adds visual interest. At under $50, it's genuinely great value for PU leather.
Best Prostate Massager: Adam's Glass Prostate Massager ($56.95)
Glass toys are criminally underrated. They're body-safe, easy to clean, temperature-play compatible, and last forever. Adam's Glass Prostate Massager is perfectly curved to hit the P-spot with precision. A thoughtful, high-quality gift for anyone who wants a different kind of anal experience.
$100+: The Good Stuff
Best Butt Plug (Advanced): 665 STRETCH'R Tripole Butt Plug – Black ($99.95)
For someone who's moved past the beginner stage and wants something more substantial: the 665 Tripole. Three-lobed design, premium silicone, serious stretch. This is a "treat yourself" buy — or a very meaningful gift for someone who knows what they like.
Best Vibe for Anal Play: 3Some Wall Banger Vibrating Anal Beads ($115)
Vibrating anal beads with a suction cup so you can go hands-free — this is the upgrade pick for anyone who already owns basic toys and wants something that does more. Multiple vibration modes, body-safe silicone, and a suction base for solo or partnered use.
Don't Forget: Always Include Lube
Seriously — any sex toy gift is better with lube. If you're including anything anal-related, grab a quality silicone-based lubricant ($24.53). It lasts longer than water-based and requires less reapplication. (Note: don't use silicone lube with silicone toys — for those, go water-based.)
A Few Gift-Buying Rules
- Body-safe materials matter. Stick to silicone, glass, stainless steel, or hard plastic (ABS). Avoid anything that says "jelly" or doesn't list materials.
- Know their experience level. A 10-inch dildo is not a great first gift. When in doubt, go smaller and higher quality.
- Lube is always a good add-on. See above.
- Discreet packaging. All orders from Toys From TIM ship in plain, unmarked packaging. No logos, no product names on the outside.
Shop the full collection at Toys From TIM — gay sex toys, BDSM gear, and kink apparel curated by the team behind Treasure Island Media.